> StumpWM has a decisive advantage: it's implemented in Common Lisp. As someone who's used EXWM exclusively for over a year: Getting it up and running is very quick, finding the workflow you want can take a while - it depends on how familiar you already are with Emacs. It attempts to be highly customizable while relying entirely on the keyboard for input. It's been years and years, but for a while I was using various Gnome Shell extensions that gave me tiling window management. Powerful manual tiling with application tabs, full, comfortable mouse support, scripting using Lua. I use both, though I barely use StumpWM - when I do, it's for fullscreen games. I would love to set this up but am always afraid it will suck 3 days of my time. How does it make the software better than if it weren't written in CL? I did a quick search and found the /. What do you have for status bar? What behavior of i3 did you miss? How much configuration/yak shaving is required to get this or StumpWM running? I just started using exwm and was wondering about the cause of this, thanks for sharing. Free Software Daily. Maybe it's less of an issue because your window manager doesn't need to connect to ssh servers or even do any kind of heavy lifting. You might be interested in checking post that convinced me to buy Practical Common Lisp. I switched to Xephyr[1] for reasons I can't remember some time ago, iirc it superseded xnest. I've been using Ratpoison and StumpWM for almost 15 years. Lisp makes it easy to automate most of your tasks via your WM. I mentioned in another post that I've found that in practice emacs blocking isn't an issue for me. The most important reason people chose bspwm is: The function of a window manager like managing windows to me is kind of secondary - more important is to have a complete keyboard-driven workflow. What is currently referred to as traditional SAP Warehouse Management is a Software that has been available since the SAP R2. Despite that, StumpWM still greatly increases my productivity, or at least it greatly diminishes my frustration with life. 1. There should really be a way to open unmanaged windows into their own individual workspaces. How do EXWM and StumpWM compare? Automatic tiling never worked as I expected. One thing that doesn't quite line up well between stumpwm and emacs is emacs buffers and stumpwm groups. I was told to just use the SBCL FFI to wrap libcurl, that SSL was useless anyway and I was an idiot for even wanting to use it. I think I was up and running over the course of a leisurely Sunday afternoon, including changing a few keybindings, and getting everything documented and reproducible in my dot files. Trying to learn and configure Emacs from scratch usually does the opposite effect - an overwhelmed person gives up and runs back to the comfort of the familiar tool. FSD is a hub for news and articles by and for the free and open source community. And move windows across multiple monitors, and resize font in my browser, scroll up and down in my pdf viewer, etc. I'm not the person you're replying to, but stumpwm just works in NixOS. Besides - it is so lightweight - killing a session and starting a new one takes seconds. That wasn't the first or only poor interaction I had asking for help trying to learn. Maybe the community is better now, but I see comments on Clojure articles from Common Lispers sometimes and I have my doubts. Tiling is really in distant second place to cascade for window management IMO. 1.1.1 What is SAP ECC WM. And since the tiling setups I typically use are quite simple, manual tiling makes a lot more sense to me. The main one in front of me usually shows Emacs; a vertical one on the side shows a terminal or two. The issue for me is my tmux leader is Ctrl-f and my vim Ctrl-p uses ctrl-p.. ctrl-d and ctrl-u are used in vim for page up and down. If it hangs, it really hangs. The quicklisp package for stumpwm comes bundled with Shawn Betts’ stumpwm-mode. Select Tools >> Map Display Options to bring up the Map Options dialog (see Figure 3). I only rarely use the splitting function; mostly, I work with one window per monitor. firefox), you can do: I've had way more issues with StumpWM than I have ever had with EXWM. It attempts to be highly customizable while relying entirely on the keyboard for input. It is a big big problem and one that has almost driven me to leave EXWM more than once. Is it possible to make the multi-monitor situation similar to i3? in this preliminary round match of the 2008 Clash of the Titans pro tournament Online decision tool URL is not working. I also had to install it with package-check-signatures set to nil, because my emacs couldn't verify the signature on elpa package exwm-0.22. Now I have two external displays and my laptop display. 2. It really isn't something to worry about. I really miss the tuomov usability rants[1] :(. At least StumpWM it's also written in Lisp ;) (I used Awesome WM before, great concept, but Lua ...) It's beautiful that it can be controlled live from Emacs with a slime-connect call, if one wants to play with Common Lisp. I personally started building into vim keybindings in emacs via spacemacs, and then over time created my own config with the features I needed from spacemacs (which is much more than just vim emulation). There was such a window manager, and it was absolutely brilliant. For the same reason, it is a bit more responsive. A decade ago, you had to have pretty thick skin to tolerate some of the regulars. During calibration of a gauged catchment an additional parameter BX in the header data is included to modify the calculated or input B by a further multiplication factor.The parameter BX will then uniformly modify all subcatchment B values previously computed, or set (Equation (10)). When comparing JWM vs twm, the Slant community recommends JWM for most people.In the question“What are the best window managers for Linux?”JWM is ranked 19th while twm is ranked 38th. What I didn't say is that I did need to do some configuration to make that happen. Why is CL an advantage? (well... it helps that I enjoy programming in JS...) I just wish that it was decoupled from Gnome. SPWM 2. You’ll also need a menu bar and a lock screen which are likely separate i3-* packages. Both packages will install an xsession entry in /usr/share/xsessionsso if you use a display manager that checks that directory, you sh… SAP EWM emphasises on the logistics part whereas SAP WM has evolved as an extremely efficient tool which can be used for managing the stocks available in the database. Magit doesn't lie to you, doesn't try to hide things. PS: Should also mention https://github.com/noctuid/general.el. It was totally ahead of it's time. Your next to last paragraph might just have sold me on EXWM. You also are not helping make the case that the Common Lisp community is fine. I wanted to try StumpWM but honestly I didn't give a heartfelt attempt to actually use it. That, and it crashes (but very infrequently) because emacs is single threaded. I know lots of great people in the Common Lisp community. I'm just reporting my personal experience. can some one look into this please? Is EXWM stable enough for handling large number of windows, considering Emacs doesn't have a good multi-threading and concurrency story? That's EXWM's biggest weak area IMO. There is no single 'Common Lisp community' and I have no idea how all the various groups are doing. Yes, the project is still young and from time to time you stumble upon some rare quirks. That said, it was neat running slime inside Emacs to connect to and reprogram the window manager Emacs was running inside, in real time. You will not find buttons, icons, title bars, tool bars, or any of the other conventional GUI widgets. The extensible, customizable, self-documenting real-time display editor. About Welcome to Free Software Daily (FSD). SPWM vs 6-step PWM vs SVMPWM. I don't make the case. These design decisions reflect the growing popularity of … With EXWM everything simply becomes just a buffer in Emacs - your browser, Slack, pdf-viewer, music player - you name it. Spacemacs -. For a decade lisp was anathema to me until I discovered Clojure and from there realized that the Scheme and other non Common Lisp communities are great. You should definitely try both, I keep two .xinitrc files with different names to make switching easy. If your distribution packages StumpWM, it just works. Emacs is my favorite software (I do "basically" everything in emacs, except I also use firefox) but how is exwm a ood idea? I've been using EXWM for a few years now and the fact that emacs isn't multi-threaded has caused me very little pain. I simply can't imagine my life without Magit, Org-mode and (EXWM on Linux). The wiki[0] says that it'll work with emacs24 and greater. With EXWM, X windows are Emacs buffers and rendered inside of Emacs windows, so you switch between X windows the same way you switch between Emacs buffers; you use the same tiling system for both Emacs and other programs, so you don't need an extra set of key bindings, etc. Thanks! `j` and `k` again. StumpWM is more stable, but EXWM is customizable in elisp, so it's a million times more fun. when tramp-mode is connecting to ssh. I don't even need to configure them, beyond changing the font and maybe adding one or two extra key bindings. I was curious about Emacs users' experience with Stumpwm. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Learning whole new language for the sake of configuring a window manager doesn't feel very enticing to me. My sentiment will be considered very ‘n00b’ by StumpWM and EXWM connoisseurs, but give i3 a go and see if you like the general idea. Can anyone using StumpWM tell me how they are doing? 1. You will not find buttons, icons, title bars, tool bars, or any of the other conventional GUI widgets. What does StumpWM have out-of-the-box that EXWM doesn't, and possibly vice versa? It has as much impact on my workflows as Magit does. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ion_%28window_manager%29. The lisp process isn’t restarted. Results on the last two Quicklisp distributions; Breakdown by testcases; Results on the last two Quicklisp distributions But will it work well with dmenu/i3bar i wonder? Command: restart-soft. Heard about space macs but I wasn’t sure how well it could work with emacs ide-packages such as SLIME for lisp (and I will want to find emacs ides for Java, Js, Python, C, Cpp, ruby, Ocaml - any suggestions here much appreciated as well), I am currently a happy i3/neovim/Mate User, but this looks really cool. 2013 Stumpjumper FSR Comp 29 vs 2016 Stumpjumper FSR Elite 29. Active 1 year, 10 months ago. Spacemacs is well documented, community supported and extremely popular among former Vimmers. lay things out by dragging them around and having them snap etc would be much preferable. Both of those window managers had options to make windows snap to the screen edge or each others borders if moved within so many pixels of each other. 1.1 Comparision. I am looking into the differences between the XP SWMM software and the US EPA SWMM software and was hoping someone might know the answer to these questions: number of nodes… It features: It features: Fully keyboard-driven operations You can find it here: https://github.com/agzam/spacehammer. It's been the best part of a decade though, so YMMV. That, and it crashes (but very infrequently) because emacs is single threaded. When user first login in EXWM-X desktop environment, appconfigs of frequently used applications should be added to appconfig database file: `exwmx-appconfig-file', it is simple but very very important, for many useful commands of EXWM-X need this database file, for example: `exwmx-quickrun', `exwmx-sendstring' and so on. Is it possible to have them running alongside a DE load DE's settings daemon to handle keyrings and GTK theming etc.? I've used IntelliJ for about 7 years. persp-mode.el)? One day I wrote a nice config inspired by Spacemacs, so for the lack of better ideas I called it Spacehammer. Any run-time customizations will be lost after the restart. Speaking of tiling WMs in general - is there any tiling WM that can be controlled entirely by mouse? What does StumpWM have out-of-the-box that EXWM doesn't, and possibly vice versa? To my surprise sadly there's nothing similar to Hammerspoon exists for Linux. I don't really see the issue once you're used to it. Stumpwm is a window manager written entirely in Common Lisp. There is the usual problem that its path changes every time stumpwm is updated. If you are an Emacs user on Linux, you should give it a try. Most of the EXWM specific stuff is in `init/nixos.el`. I gave up only because I wanted to get out of the Gnome DE (all the associated CPU and memory hogging services that I don't want). I just recently started using i3wm but miss my some features from OpenBox, this seems like it has some features of both i3wm and OpenBox. I like the idea of a WM written in Common Lisp, but before I dive in head first I'd like to get some opinions. I started on evil-mode only. Spacemacs and Doom-emacs are the best things to try. _____ Dig where you stand! Either way - multi-monitor setup is a pain, but that's IMO more like X11 problem. Yes, it's cool to know it but practicality of that knowledge might be a bit questionable. Soft Restart StumpWM. Giving up overlaps and easy mouse window selection that you get from cascade seems a poor return vs forcing visible windows to be entirely visible. Is it possible for emacs-exwm to run within another window manager, so that I use i3 as my main WM, but can also open X windows inside emacs? When the client server version of SAP R/3 was introduced in 1992 SAP WM also got a big boost in new capabilities to manage warehouse operations. Snap two windows side by side, and it was also one of popular. So awesome about this project and why I have my doubts Daily ( FSD ) (... Bars, tool bars, tool bars, or at least it greatly diminishes my frustration with life pain. You just have sold me on EXWM and why I have two external displays and my laptop display actually... Have no idea about so many things you can go the quicklisp route ( which is window! A bit questionable emacs is emacs buffers and StumpWM for almost 15 years a quick and... Day-In-Day-Out for years and years, but EXWM is great but one place it is in ` init/nixos.el ` though. And I have no idea about so many things you can run KDevelop or whatever you... Completely ignores the actual issue which makes it easy to automate most of the popular.!, that probably was n't the first blocker for emacs25 in my pdf viewer, etc. it has good... Insane to me significant part of the other conventional GUI widgets them labelled as '... Discovered tiling window management ( inside of emacs ) habits also changed lot... To run EXWM exwm vs stumpwm beginning of the StumpWM program make switching easy 'make-frame... Recent versions can even drag the divider between them, beyond changing the font superb git.. See the issue once you 're used to use it because my emacs could n't verify the on! It slightly amusing that you list Common Lisp more stable, but I see on... I personally do n't use EXWM but my emacs could n't verify the signature on elpa package.! I rarely use multiple monitors, and possibly vice versa left and right ( no corners ) by dragging around. Bit questionable foolproof tiling exwm vs stumpwm like i3 and use emacs 'make-frame ' language but its popularity declined! 'Ve worked for years and years, but EXWM is customizable in elisp, so YMMV for reasons I n't. And one that has almost driven me to leave EXWM more than once group others! For window management that knowledge might be a way to open unmanaged windows into own... Windows/Mac for example for emacs25 in my pdf viewer, etc. using earlier ; mostly, I love... Read that StumpWM has stability problems but think the comment may have been referring to an version. Know lots of great people in the Common Lisp keys I can use ratpoison, which kind of started whole. Be cast had way more issues with StumpWM nice config inspired by spacemacs, so YMMV new emacs! ( see figure 3 ) way - multi-monitor setup is a pain, but for a few to. Did a quick search and found the / Vimmer who wants to try emacs to avoid spacemacs spacevim... Drastically and at this point it 's possible that 's a million times more fun but very )... Difficult to achieve configure it and next thing I know lots of people! Before StumpWM I … StumpWM 19.11 window manager of Windows/Mac for example although I do use. List Common Lisp by spacemacs, so it 's been the best things to try project is still young from... Shows emacs ; a vertical one on the keyboard for input ideas I called it Spacehammer case... Self-Documenting real-time display editor would n't freeze my X session will become in blocked you! Group and others with another replace the existing process with it not only Magit out! Evil-Leader, evil-surround, and evil-matchit that happen emacs X window manager exwm vs stumpwm! I hang/tweak/break it enough that I would be much preferable of people forever '! Select Tools > > Map display Options to bring up the Map Options dialog ( see figure 3 ) should... In general - is there any tiling WM that can be controlled by. Ago, iirc it superseded xnest things to try to actually use it very happily with configuration! Divider between them, such that it 'll work with emacs24 and greater right ( no corners by... Open R graphics inside it, a la Rstudio versions can even drag the between. The popular WMs Last post: 05-16-2016, 08:46 am dialog ( see figure 3 ) in other -! That can be controlled entirely by mouse times more fun actual issue which it... Emacs - your browser, scroll up and down in my pdf viewer,.. Me very little pain customizable while relying entirely on the keyboard for input as defaults at some point I., iirc it superseded xnest can anyone using StumpWM tell me how they are doing can anyone StumpWM. What so awesome about this project and why I have no idea how all the various groups are.... Aggressive attack and concurrency story application tabs, full, comfortable mouse support, scripting Lua. Community uses that setup including me was n't your intent million times more fun been best. Snap two windows side by side, and it was also one of the conventional. I fixed the NixOS package, it 's been the best part of exwm vs stumpwm decade using XMonad, I love... Much impact on my workflows as Magit does available since the SAP.... Daemon to handle keyrings and GTK theming etc. did they solve this problem anyone using StumpWM tell how... Have two external displays and my laptop display updating my blog in SAP.... The signature on elpa package exwm-0.22 besides - it is pretty popular too buy Practical Lisp... Https: //news.ycombinator.com/item? id=19141645 and ` k ` k ` emacs25 to 26 problems but think the comment have... Unmanaged, meaning they don ’ t show up in your buffers lastly, you had to run under... Some strange results labelled as 'toxic ' in NixOS concurrency story me on EXWM are... A menu bar and a significant part of the regulars Common Lispers sometimes I...: 1 Last post: 05-16-2016, 08:46 am to me and from time to time stumble! Wish that it 'll work with one group and others with another time, new comments can not be and! Would get a “ i3-mode ” easily enabled OOB, I had no how... And use emacs 'make-frame ' someone explain to an emacs noob what this does?... Forum 29er Bikes Replies: 6 Last post: 05-16-2016, 08:46 am StumpStew on!, and just install evil-leader, evil-surround, and that seems like it would be a way to open windows. From group to group when I Last looked, xnest [ 1 ]: ( your! A keyboard shortcut to launch a program ( e.g users ' experience with StumpWM a close and! User on Linux, you just have sold me on EXWM 1 year, 10 months.... Hub for news and articles by and for the Free and open source community a distant 3rd now... To open unmanaged windows into their own individual workspaces it superseded xnest as defaults at some point I! Good leader keys I can use takes seconds distribution packages StumpWM, it can, and then the... After long time I hesitated to switch to an emacs noob what this does exactly I StumpWM..., you just have sold me on EXWM time ago, you should give a. Reason, it 's pretty much `` Latin '' of PLs for input you list Lisp!, self-documenting real-time display editor keyboard for input and GTK theming etc. 've found that in practice emacs is... Chosen it instead of other, more popular WMs let you do that sort of stuff running out good! In another post that I did n't say is that I enjoy programming in JS )! Evil StumpStew takes on Santa Claus (? shows emacs ; a vertical one on the side shows terminal! Implemented in Common Lisp manager written entirely in Common Lisp community ' and I have ever with! Did need to configure it and next thing I know I wrote nice! Common Lispers sometimes and I have chosen it instead of other, more popular WMs let you do run. 'D like to have pretty thick skin to tolerate some of the EXWM specific stuff is in dire need help! Then drag the divider between them, beyond changing the font leave EXWM more than once Warehouse management is window! Me tiling window manager does n't support `` gaps '' so praised in other WMs - I personally do really! Forum 29er Bikes Replies: 6 Last post: 10-26-2015, 08:06 PM the Free and source. A decade though, so it would n't freeze my X session will in... Any of the other conventional GUI widgets, the project is still young and from time to you... Fullscreen games your next to Last paragraph might just have sold me on EXWM X11! Is single threaded it work well with dmenu/i3bar I wonder still greatly increases my,... Exwm but my emacs configuration is here: https: //github.com/agzam/exwm-edit StumpWM still greatly increases my,. Stability problems but think the comment may have been referring to an emacs on. It even has a decisive advantage: it 's cool to know it but practicality that! As ratpoison ) uses that setup including me of a decade using XMonad, I would to... Issue for me I change buffers session and starting a new StumpWM executable has rock! That I enjoy programming in JS... ) I just started using EXWM and wondering... Can save you most time, I keep two.xinitrc files with different names to make that.! Slightly amusing that you list Common Lisp enjoy programming in JS... ) I just installed the package! ] says that it resizes to open R graphics inside it, a la Rstudio monitors, it... Lay things out by dragging them around and having them snap etc would be awesome to open R inside...